Thursday, July 9, 2020

Kate and Gerry McCann: The Great Difference between the Truth and a Lie

The great difference between the truth and a lie is that the truth is usually simple and a lie is invariably complicated.

"We went out to dinner leaving the kids most nights and we came back and they were still there" is really simple.

As is, unfortunately, "We went out one night leaving the kids but one of them got out of the apartment and fell off the balcony". Or, "We went out one night leaving the kids and we got back and one of them had had a serious accident". Or, "We went out one night leaving the kids and we got back and one of them had got out and been run over by a car."

The alternative is somewhat more complicated: "We went out one night leaving the kids, not realising that we'd been watched by a predatory paedophile for several days, who we hadn't noticed, despite the resort being quiet and despite the fact that we felt it was safe to leave the kids, who targeted Madeleine rather than the other kids because she was special, who got into the apartment between our checks, despite the fact we'd doubled the frequency from the night before following the crying incident, which we can't recall happening, avoiding being noticed by Gerry, who was talking to Jez, on the other side of the road to that claimed by Jez and Jane, who wasn't seen by Jez or Gerry anyway, just before she saw the abductor, who must have gone out through the window, despite no-one noticing it open and without leaving any marks, because the door slammed and the curtains whooshed when Kate went in, and it's odd about those dogs, but Kate had handled dead bodies when she went to work in her holiday pants and took the cuddle cat, and anyway the twins' sandals were in the boot of the car with the dirty nappies and the rotting meat, but we're totally confident in each other's innocence and our legal and PR team are too."

Now ask yourself why all these people are involved:

Saturday, June 20, 2020

PRESS FREEDOM The Good, the Bad, and the VERY Ugly in Journalism

New chapter from PeterMac's e-book: 'What really happened to Madeleine McCann?'

The Good, the Bad, and the VERY Ugly in Journalism

A free press is one of the foundations on which modern ‘liberal’ democracy rests.
“ Freedom of speech ” has long been recognized as important “If freedom of speech is taken away, then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter.” George Washington
We have become used to reading and hearing, and more recently actually seeing, proceedings in Parliament. Our Parliament. It was not always so.
Hansard, which publishes a verbatim but edited record of proceedings in the House, was founded only in 1771. Before that date only decisions had been reported, not the content of the debate, and to attempt to do so was punishable by both Houses. A commentary at the time refers to "the difficulties faced by independent newspapermen who . . . in varying degrees, attempted to educate the populace to the shortcomings of their rulers.” Hansard we know today began only in 1909.          
We have also become accustomed to access to a range of newspapers. We accept that each will have its own political agenda reflected in the leader article or evidenced by the general tone of the editorial and commentary.
There was a time when journalism was a respected profession. It was referred to as the 4th Estate, with a mission to hold the Establishment to account by reporting the truth and by fearlessly exposing corruption and deceit.
Thomas Carlyle attributed the origin of the term to Edmund Burke, who used it in a parliamentary debate in 1787 on the opening up of press reporting of the House of Commons of Great Britain
     "Burke said there were Three Estates in Parliament; but, in the Reporters' Gallery yonder, there sat a Fourth Estate more important far than they all”

Relatively quickly however, that importance and power began to corrupt. As Lord Acton observed in 1887 “Power tends to corrupt. Absolute power corrupts absolutely”
Oscar Wilde wrote in his 1891 pamphlet The Soul of Man under Socialism:
     "In old days men had the rack. Now they have the Press. That is an improvement certainly. But still it is very bad, and wrong, and demoralising. Somebody — was it Burke? — called journalism the fourth estate. That was true at the time no doubt. But at the present moment it is the only estate. It has eaten up the other three. The Lords Temporal say nothing, the Lords Spiritual have nothing to say, and the House of Commons has nothing to say and says it. We are dominated by Journalism."

Though he was also scathing about its purpose: “There is much to be said in favour of modern journalism. By giving us the opinions of the uneducated, it keeps us in touch with the ignorance of the community.“ 
What are the gradations, the categories of truth and of truth telling?
Is truth indivisible? Can it have context or nuance?
Can you have your personal “version of the truth”?
Can it be placed onto a scale according to some level or quantum of truth or mendacity, or by assessing the spectrum of damage caused to individuals and to the freedom of us all?
And when that truth is reported, what then?
I have tried to fit it into a scale here.
(I use the word Truth to mean objective and provable fact, and I use Mendacity to mean deliberate, calculated falsehood, as opposed to error, mistake, misunderstanding, or misinterpretation.)
You may observe that I include a category not normally associated with Journalism, but I believe intimately concerned with Truth and Mendacity and able to influence freedom of speech. Libel Lawyers.

Let me try to develop this


'Maddie: The Truth of the Lie' 'The McCanns and the Conman' 50 Facts Abduction hoax Alpha Investigations Group ALPHAIG Amy Tierney Angolan Bouncer AnnaEsse Anti-McCann trolls Antonio Jimenez Raso Antonio Tamarit Apartment 5J Arade Dam Arthur Cowley Attempted burglary Baron Daniel Cardon de Lichtbuer BBC Crimewatch Bell Pottinger Ben Salmon Blackwatch BNFL Brian Kennedy Bugau Burgau Cadaver dogs Cadaverine Carole Tranmer Carter-Ruck Casualties Cat Baker CEOP Charlotte Pennington Cherie Blair Chief Inspector Tavares de Almeida Churnalism Clarence Mitchell CMOMM Coloboma COMARE Commissioner Cressida Dick Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe Control Risks Group Cover-up cowering Creche records Criminal Profiler Pat Brown cuddlecat Curtains Dave Edgar DCI Andy Redwood DCI Ian Horrocks DCI Nicola Wall DCS Hamish Campbell Deleted call records Discrepancies Doberman Gang Dr Arul Savio Gaspar Dr David Payne Dr Fiona Payne Dr Gerry McCann Dr Joe Sullivan Dr John Synnott Dr Julian Totman Dr Katarina Gaspar Dr Kate McCann Dr Martin Roberts Dr Vernon Coleman Dr. Christian Lüdke DRª JOANA MARQUES VIDAL Dutroux Affair Eddie Eddie and Keela Edward Smethurst Enhanced Victim Recovery Dogs Ernie Allen Eve Branson Fake News Find Madeleine Fund FOI's Forged Francisco Marco Fraud Freud Communications Gary Hagland Gerry McCann GMC Gonçalo Amaral Gordon Brown Green ink Henri Exton HideHo HMI holiday photos Holiday weather Home Office House of Commons Huddersfield University Ethics Committee IFL IMEC Jacqui Smith James Whale Jane Tanner Jeffrey Epstein jemmied window Jenny Murat Jez Wilkins Jill Dando Jim Gamble Jimmy Saville Jon Clarke Journalism Julian Peribanez Kate and Gerry McCann Kate McCann Kate McCann's book Kevin Halligen La Cortina da Humo La Cortina de Humo Lady Catherine Meyers Last Photo Latium Group Leicestershire Police Leonor Cipriano Letter to Portuguese Attorney-General Lies Maddie Madeleine Foundation Madeleine McCann Madeleine McCann Research Group Make-Up Photo Marcelino Italiano Marcos Aragao Correia Mark Hollingsworth Mark Saunokonoko Mark Warner Mark Williams-Thomas Martin Brunt Martin Smith Mason Hosrbrough Matthew Amroliwala mccannfiles Melissa Little Mentorn Films MET Police Metodo 3 Metodo3 MI5 MI5’s Covert Intelligence Section MI6 Michael Caplan QC Michael Wright Missing People MMRG money laundering Murder Natasha Donn National Audit Office NCMEC Netflix Nigel Moore Nigel Nessling Nuno Lourenco Oakley International Ocean Club staff Operation Ballast Operation Grange Operation Midland Operation Ore Oprah PACT PACT. ICEMC paedophilia Palladium Associates Pamela Fenn Pat Brown Paulo Reis Peter Hyatt PeterMac Phone records PJ Playground Photo Police Integrity Unit Polícia Judiciária Pool Photo Portugal Resident PR Press Standards and Libel Prime Minister David Cameron Prime Minister Theresa May Prince Andrew Priti Patel Private Eyes Prosecution Exhibit 1: 'madeleine' Publicity pyjamas racing pigeons Ray Wyre Real IRA Red Defence Ltd Red flags Resonate Richard D. Hall Robert Murat Sagres Sajid Javid Salsalito Summit Sedation Sergei Malinka sex trafficking Shutters Sightings Sir Clement Freud Sir Richard Branson Smithman Solimar Staged abduction Statement analyst Surrey Police Tania Cadogan Tannerman Tavares de Almeida Tennis Balls Photo Textusa The Establishment The Olive Press The Podesta Brothers The Rt Hon Priti Patel The Sun Tim-Craig-Harvey Timeline of staged abduction Tony Bennett Tony Blair Twins Sean and Amelie Vicky Pollard Victoria Beckham Wayback Machine Weather Welt Online Wendy Murphy whooshing curtains Wild goose chase window of opportunity Witness Statements Witnesses Wojchiech Krokowski

My Blog List

Popular Posts